The French franchise market has experienced significant growth in recent years, making it crucial for businesses to understand the intricacies of intellectual property rights protection. This comprehensive guide explores the French legal framework governing franchise trademarks and provides essential insights for international franchisors.
1. Introduction
Current State of Franchising in France
France stands out as one of the most mature markets for franchising in Europe, with over 2,000 franchise networks and around 75,000 franchised points of sale across the country.
According to the Franchise Observatory, franchising generates almost €80 billion in annual sales, or around 10% of the total retail turnover in France. In 2024, the sector continues to grow at a steady pace, with an increase of almost 7% per year, according to data from L’Express Franchise.
The expansion of the catering, distribution, and service sectors reflects this dynamic, contributing to the strength of the franchising business model. The franchising market has thus become a major pillar of the French economy, attracting not only local entrepreneurs but also international investors.
Importance of IP Rights Protection
In the French franchise ecosystem, the protection of trademarks is a central element of brand value and corporate identity. The brand, as a distinctive element, plays a crucial role in creating consumer recognition and loyalty. Effective legal protection of IP rights not only ensures the integrity of the franchise system, but also ensures brand consistency and reputation across all franchised outlets.
The French legal system for trademarks is based on mechanisms such as the Intellectual Property Code, and franchises enjoy strong protection, including at the international level through agreements such as the Madrid Protocol, which facilitates the registration of trademarks in several jurisdictions at once.
2. French Legal Framework for Franchise IP
Key Legislation
The main legislative frameworks for the intellectual property of franchises in France are :
- Code of Intellectual Property (CPI) : It governs the rights of trademarks, their registration, use, and protection against infringement.
- Doubin Law (Law No. 89-1008 of December 31, 1989) : It requires franchisors to provide comprehensive information to franchise applicants, including detailed information on the intellectual property rights related to the brand.
Regulatory Bodies
At a national level, the Institut National de la Propriété Industrielle (INPI) in France plays a key role in the registration and protection of trademarks at the national level. Indeed, INPI oversees the process of filing, managing and controlling trademarks registered in France.
At an European level, trademark protection is provided by the European Union Office for Intellectual Property (EUIPO). The organisation manages the registration of European Union trade marks (EUTM) and allows businesses to enjoy uniform protection across the 27 EU member states through a single registration.
EU Influence
As a member of the European Union, France applies European trademark regulations. These European sources complement and influence the Intellectual Property Code, ensuring consistency between national law and European obligations.
- Directive (EU) 2015/2436 : It harmonizes the laws of the Member States of the European Union on trade marks, strengthening the protection and recognition of trade marks in the European territory.
- The European Union Trade Mark Regulation (EU) 2017/1001 : It establishes a single framework for EU trade marks (EUTM), which offer unitary protection across the 27 member states.
The European Union trademark system (EUTM) is a key component of these regulations, allowing for uniform trademark protection in all EU member states.
3. Trademark Registration Process
Requirements
For a trademark to be eligible for registration in France, it has to meet several legal criteria. They aim to ensure that the trademark fulfills its distinctive functions while respecting the rights of third parties and public order requirements.
Distinctive character
The trademark has to be able to distinguish the goods or services of a company from those of other companies. It must allow the consumer to identify the commercial origin of the product or service. For example, a logo, word or symbol that is evocative but unique can be considered distinctive.
Possible refusal : The authorities will reject signs that are too generic, such as common terms or banal expressions directly related to products or services, because they do not allow for clear differentiation in the market.
Lack of Descriptive or Customary Character
A trademark cannot be descriptive or customary in relation to the goods or services it designates. This ensures that these terms remain usable by all market operators.
- Descriptive : Terms that simply designate a characteristic of products or services, such as their quality, nature or destination cannot be registered.
- Common : Signs commonly used in trade to designate the goods or services concerned are excluded from protection.
Compliance with Public Policy and Morality Standards
The mark must not violate public order or morals and must not be misleading or deceptive :
- Public order and morality : Signs that contain offensive, racist, or contrary to the fundamental values of society will be rejected.
- Misleading : A trademark must not mislead the consumer as to the nature, quality or geographical origin of the goods or services.
Availability
The mark must be available. In other words, it must not conflict with earlier rights. You must conduct an antecedent search before filing a trademark registration application to ensure that no one has registered similar or identical trademarks for similar goods or services.
Legal basis : Articles L.711-2 of the CPI and 7 of EU Regulation No. 2017/1001
Timeline and Costs
The process of registering a trademark in France is relatively straightforward but involves specific timelines and costs. Typically, the entire registration procedure takes around 6 months, depending on the complexity of the application and any potential objections.
- Basic filing fee : The standard filing fee starts at €190 for a trademark application in a single class of goods or services.
- Additional class fees : There is an extra fee of €40 per additional class.
- Renewal fees : Trademarks in France are valid for 10 years from the date of registration. To maintain protection, trademark owners must renew their registration every 10 years, with renewal fees typically similar to the initial application fees.
For further information on the costs and timeline of the trademark registration process, you can refer to the INPI website here.
4. IP Rights in Franchise Agreements
In franchising, IP rights are fundamental to ensuring the consistency and recognition of the franchise system. A franchise agreement inherently includes a trademark license, granting the franchisee the right to use the franchisor’s distinctive signs, such as logos, brand names, and other trademarks, in exchange for royalties.
Essential Provisions
Franchise agreements must include specific IP-related clauses to safeguard the franchisor’s intellectual property and allow the franchisee to use it in a controlled manner.
- Scope of trademark license: It specifies clearly which trademarks, logos, brand names and other intellectual property elements the franchisee is allowed to use.
- Usage guidelines and restrictions : Franchise agreements have to regulate how the franchisee may use the franchisor’s trademarks and other intellectual property.
- It covers aspects such as the use of logos, colors, and fonts.
- It prohibits unauthorized alterations or misrepresentations of the brand.
- Quality control measures: These measures allow the franchisor to monitor the franchisee’s operations to ensure they comply with the brand’s standards.
- It includes regular inspections, audits and reporting obligations.
- Post-termination obligations : The franchisee has to immediately cease using the franchisor’s trademarks, trade names and any other intellectual property upon termination of the agreement. This ensures that the franchisor’s IP is not exploited by former franchisees and that the brand’s identity is protected.
Licensing Terms
Franchise agreements must also outline the terms of the trademark license :
- Duration of trademark usage rights : The franchisor typically ties the length of the franchise agreement to the duration for which the franchisee is granted the right to use the franchisor’s trademarks.
- Territorial restrictions : The franchisor may want to limit the use of the trademark to specific geographical areas. Territorial restrictions help franchisees avoid conflicts and ensure that the brand controls and expands in a structured way.
- Sub-licensing provisions : It outlines whether the franchisee is allowed to grant the trademark license to other parties.
- Compliance requirements : It ensures that franchisees follow the legal and operational guidelines set forth by the franchisor. Non-compliance can lead to legal consequences like the termination of the franchise agreement.
Trademark License in Franchise Agreements
The trademark license is a contractual arrangement through which the trademark holder (franchisor) grants the franchisee the right to use its trademark while retaining ownership. In a franchise context, this typically grants a simple license to multiple franchisees within the same network.
You must register the trademark license with the National Trademark Register to ensure its validity and enforceability in case of disputes or infringement. The franchise agreement may specify which party is responsible for carrying out the necessary registration procedures.
Legal basis : Article L.714-7 of the CPI
5. Protection and Enforcement
The protection and enforcement of intellectual property rights, particularly trademarks, are crucial for maintaining the integrity of intellectual assets. In France, various legal mechanisms are in place to ensure such protection.
Legal Remedies
In France, trademark owners have access to several legal remedies to protect their intellectual property rights from infringement and unauthorized use. These remedies are designed to offer both preventive and corrective measures :
Civil actions for trademark infringement : Trademark rights are intangible property that grant their owner the ability to prevent others from using or exploiting their mark without authorization. Infringement leads to an infringement action.
Competent court : The judicial Court is competent for infringement cases.
Statute of limitations : It is 5 years, starting from the date when the trademark owner became aware, or should have reasonably become aware, of the infringement.
Damages : They are calculated either circumstantial (based on actual losses and profits) or lump-sum (based on a fixed amount determined by the court).
Legal basis : Articles L.716-9, L.716-10 and L.716-4-2 of the CPI
Criminal penalties for counterfeiting : The counterfeiter incurs a primary penalty of up to €400,000 in fine and 4 years in prison.
Legal basis : Articles L.716-9 and L.716-4-10 of the CPI
Customs seizures for imported counterfeit goods : French customs authorities can seize counterfeit goods entering the country and any materials used to produce them.
They can be recovered and handed over to the trademark holder.
They can be destroyed to prevent their circulation.
Legal basis : Article L.716-4-7 of the CPI
Dispute Resolution
Trademark disputes can be resolved through :
- French commercial courts : French commercial courts handle trademark-related disputes, specializing in resolving issues involving commercial matters, including intellectual property rights.
- Arbitration : Arbitration provides a legal form of private justice and people favor it for its discretion, speed, and high-quality decision-making. It provides an efficient and confidential way to resolve trademark disputes without the need for public court proceedings.
- Mediation : It involves a neutral third party helping the disputing parties reach a mutually agreeable solution. Mediation is often quicker and less formal than court proceedings, preserving business relationships and offering a more flexible approach to resolving conflicts.
6. Best Practices and Recommendations
To ensure effective trademark protection in French franchising :
- Conduct comprehensive trademark searches before entering the market
- Register trademarks in all relevant classes
- Maintain detailed usage guidelines
- Monitor market for potential infringements
- Establish clear enforcement procedures
Conclusion
Understanding and navigating the French legal framework for franchise trademarks is crucial for successful franchise operations in France. By following proper registration procedures, implementing comprehensive agreements, and maintaining vigilant enforcement strategies, franchisors can effectively protect their intellectual property rights in the French market.
For specific guidance on trademark protection strategies or legal assistance, consult with qualified French intellectual property attorneys or franchise law specialists.
Address: 14th floor, HM Town Building, 412 Nguyen Thi Minh Khai, Ward 05, District 3, Ho Chi Minh City.
Phone: +84 937215585
Website: hmlf.vn
Email: [email protected]